Posts

Showing posts from September, 2017

A Defense of Brett

Through class discussions, I can tell that the overall opinion of Brett is overwhelmingly negative, for good reasons. She has been an asshole treating men throughout the story poorly by leashing them along without fulling committing to either one. In the middle of a fling with one guy, she easily moves on to another person. By today's standards, this type of relationship is immoral as every one of Brett's relationships are one sided. The men are deeply in love and stay faithful while Brett shows no commitment leading the men to act like tortured souls. It is perfectly reasonable to find aversion to this because a lot of people are taught to stay faithful to their partner. But in defense of Brett, I think its the men who pursue Brett at more fault than Brett herself when it comes to her dysfunctional relationships because Brett loves being non-exclusive while all the other men just want her for themselves. I think open relationships are perfectly fine as long as b...

Jake and Cohn: How close is their friendship really

When Robert Cohn was first introduced by Jake in the first chapter, it seemed as if Jake disliked Robert. In the first paragraph, Jake outright downplays Cohn's middleweight boxing champion status and even goes as far to say that he was suspicious that Cohn had even got the title. He also described Cohn as a pushover who was easily controlled by women that were nice and showed him attention. But even with these negative descriptions of Cohn, he is still Jake's "Tennis friend" with the two of them interacting quite a bit in the book so far, seemingly cordially. But I think there is a characteristic of Cohn that stops his and Jake's relationship at the acquaintance line, without ever passing into the true friendship zone. That characteristic is Cohn's un-manliness. Jake tries to be as manly as possible. Having fought through WWI, he was left with no choice by his peers but to turn away all feminine qualities and tough everything out. Tragically, he left the wa...

The Dating Game

When she was young, Clarissa Dalloway seemed to have a pretty active romantic life where two men where trying to marry her, Richard Dalloway and Peter Walsh. In the book, Clarissa revisits her past a lot, often thinking about all the choices she made and if she had made the right ones, especially choices regarding the choice of marrying Richard or Peter. Each man serve a different role. Peter is the guy she seems genuinely happy to talk to since he is always able to give her something interesting to talk and think about. To me there seems to be a sort of deeper understanding and passion between the two characters, as can be seen in the way Peter keeps thinking back at Clarissa. But the two of them were a bit too close and Clarissa felt that she would feel suffocated if she married Peter. Richard on the other hand is someone who doesn't seem like he's able to stimulate Clarissa in any way. He seems like an awkward teenager on a first date whenever he is around her and so a deep ...